4.b.4.1. Internal Degradation Threats
Transmission Errors:
- Accumulating copying errors distort original meaning
- Generational changes in understanding create drift
- Simplification for broader audiences reduces sophistication
- Translation across languages and cultures introduces variation
Defensive Responses:
- Authoritative source maintenance and reference checking
- Expert training and certification programs
- Quality control processes and error detection systems
- Multiple transmission channels providing cross-validation
Internal Contradictions:
- Logical inconsistencies create vulnerability to refutation
- Competing interpretations fragment unity
- Scale expansion reveals hidden incompatibilities
- New applications expose previously unnoticed problems
Defensive Responses:
- Systematic logical analysis and consistency checking
- Hierarchical authority structures to resolve disputes
- Formal revision processes to address discovered problems
- Research programs to extend and refine system foundations
4.b.4.2. External Competition Threats
Superior Alternatives:
- New systems offer better solutions to the same problems
- Technological advancement makes old approaches obsolete
- Cultural evolution shifts away from system assumptions
- Economic changes alter the value proposition
Defensive Responses:
- Innovation and improvement to maintain competitive advantage
- Niche specialization to avoid direct competition
- Strategic alliances with complementary systems
- Aggressive marketing and propaganda campaigns
Environmental Changes:
- Political shifts remove institutional support
- Economic crises reduce available resources
- Social changes undermine cultural compatibility
- Technological disruption eliminates traditional substrates
Defensive Responses:
- Diversification across multiple environments and substrates
- Adaptive flexibility to accommodate changing conditions
- Resource stockpiling and alternative funding development
- Strategic positioning to benefit from anticipated changes
4.b.4.3. Host Rejection and Resistance
Autonomous Host Development:
- Education and critical thinking reduce host dependency
- Alternative systems provide competing options
- Personal growth reduces system relevance
- Social support networks diminish system importance
Defensive Responses:
- Continuous value demonstration and improvement
- Integration with identity and community to increase switching costs
- Adaptation to accommodate host development and autonomy
- Symbiotic evolution that benefits both system and host
Collective Resistance:
- Social movements organize opposition to the system
- Institutional changes remove support structures
- Cultural shifts delegitimize system claims
- Political processes implement restrictive regulations
Defensive Responses:
- Counter-movements and advocacy organizations
- Political lobbying and influence campaigns
- Cultural positioning and narrative management
- Legal challenges and constitutional protections
<< Previous: Stability Patterns Across Information System Types | Up: Information as an Active, Evolving System | Next: Implications for Information System Design >>